Insights

AI Disclosure and Creator Trust: What Shoppers Want Brands to Know This Peak Season

Exclusive Rakuten Advertising research across five markets shows that AI disclosure can build creator trust, but only when AI supports rather than replaces the creator’s voice. Here’s what that means for peak season.

This peak season, from Singles’ Day, through Cyber Week and beyond, shoppers want creators to do the homework for them. Product reviews, comparisons, and discount codes top their wish list. Yet these are also the formats where shoppers are least comfortable with AI. Exclusive Rakuten Advertising research across the US, UK, Australia, France, and Brazil shows that AI disclosure can build creator trust, but only when AI supports rather than replaces the creator’s judgment. 

Our latest survey found that only 38% of consumers would be comfortable with a creator using AI to generate an entire product review. That creates a real challenge for brands. Peak is when partner programs are under the most pressure to scale content fast, yet it’s also when shoppers most want one thing to stay human: the honest opinion. Here’s what the data means for your creator and partner strategy, and how to protect trust when it matters most. 

Do Consumers Know Creators Use AI?

Yes. Across the five markets surveyed, 83% of consumers are somewhat or very aware that creators use AI tools, and 46% say they notice it frequently. Awareness is highest in Brazil, where 63% are very aware, and lowest in Australia, at 30%.

For brands, the takeaway is simple: disclosure rarely reveals a secret. It confirms what most audiences already suspect. Younger shoppers are especially alert: 92% of Gen Z are aware that creators use AI, and more than half notice it frequently. If AI use goes unmentioned, audiences are likely to spot it anyway, and a creator who seems to be hiding something loses the credibility that makes their recommendations worth acting on.

For partner marketers, losing that credibility has a direct commercial cost, because creator partnerships rely on audiences trusting a recommendation enough to act on it. Our survey found that 23% of consumers have bought a product directly through a creator’s link or code, which means keeping that trust intact is as much about protecting performance as it is about doing the right thing.

Where Shoppers Draw the Line on AI in Creator Content

Consumers accept AI when it supports a creator’s work and push back when it replaces the creator’s judgment.

Translation is the most widely accepted use case, with 54% of consumers saying they are comfortable with creators using AI to translate content into other languages. Photo and video editing follows at 46%. These production tasks feel acceptable because the creator’s voice remains intact.

Comfort drops to 38% for AI-generated reviews or recommendations and falls further for AI-generated images of products that do not exist in real life.

The pattern is clear: shoppers don’t object to AI as a tool. They object to AI as the voice. A translated caption still reflects the creator’s judgment, but a generated review does not. For brands, that is the line to respect. Reviews and recommendations are the creator content that shoppers rely on most at peak. They’re also the content that drives action in partner programs, where a creator’s opinion is often the final nudge before a click or purchase. If that opinion feels automated, the partnership loses its value.

How AI Disclosure Affects Creator Trust

Overall, AI disclosure is more likely to increase trust than reduce it. Across all five markets, 45% of shoppers say disclosure would increase their trust, compared with 26% who say it would decrease it. Another 29% say it would make no difference.

But the impact varies by market. Trust gains are strongest in Brazil and the US, while Australia is nearly evenly split.

Table describes the variation of trust in AI based on global markets

Age plays a role as well with millennials being the most receptive. 52% of them say disclosure would increase their trust whereas boomers are the only group where more people say disclosure would lower trust than raise it.

Even among those whose trust would drop, the most common concern is still transparency: half say they want to know when AI is used.

Why Shoppers Accept AI for Themselves but Not for Creators

While 66% of shoppers have used an AI tool to help them shop, and they trust AI recommendations almost as much as creator recommendations, many remain uneasy when creators use AI in the same way.

Much of that comes down to control. When shoppers use AI themselves, they choose the question and judge the answer, but when a creator uses AI without saying so, they lose that control without realising it. Disclosure gives some of it back by letting the audience decide how much weight to give the content, which is why it tends to build trust rather than erode it.

How Brands Should Brief Creators About AI Disclosure for Peak Season

The takeaway for brands is simple: keep AI behind the scenes, keep opinions human, and be clear about where AI was used.

  • Keep reviews and recommendations in the creator’s own words. These are the formats shoppers want most and the ones they are least willing to hand over to AI.
  • Use AI for production, not persuasion. Translation and editing are where audiences are most comfortable.
  • Avoid AI-generated products that do not exist. This tested as the least acceptable use of AI.
  • Adapt disclosure by market. In the US and Brazil, clear disclosure appears more likely to be rewarded. In Australia, and with older audiences, brands may need to explain what AI did and did not do.
  • Build on habits audiences already understand. 60% say clear disclosure of paid partnerships builds trust, so AI labels can sit naturally alongside familiar disclosures such as #ad.

This peak shopping season, AI disclosure should be part of every creator brief, not an afterthought. The data does not suggest shoppers want less AI in every context. It suggests they want clarity about where AI fits and confidence that the opinion is still the creator’s own.

Closing Thoughts

Peak season puts brands in a difficult position, with pressure to produce more creator content, faster, at exactly the moment shoppers are paying closest attention to whether that content is real. AI can help with the first problem, but used carelessly, it makes the second one worse.

The good news is that the data points to a clear way forward. Shoppers don’t want less AI in every context, but they do want clarity about where it fits and confidence that the opinion is still the creator’s own. Brands that build disclosure into their creator partnerships now will head into Cyber Week with audiences who trust what their partners recommend, which is worth far more than extra content.

Want to put these insights to work in your peak strategy? Talk to the Rakuten Advertising team about building creator partnerships that earn trust and drive results.

Source: Suzy x Rakuten Advertising, Holiday Shopping Intentions survey, September 2026. Markets: US, UK, Australia, France and Brazil.